
Asphalt roofing is easier to install, so labor costs can be eliminated altogether by those seeking to do it themselves.įor a 2,000 - square - foot roof, an asphalt roof can cost between $5,000–$10,000 before installation.
Installation costs for asphalt roofing range from less than most types of metal roofing to next to nothing for those who choose to install it themselves. Installing metal roofing requires specialized personnel and equipment, which raises the overall price tag.įor an average ranch home roof of 2,000 square feet, a metal roof can cost $10,000–$18,000, including installation.
In addition to more expensive materials, you must account for installation when considering metal roof vs.
Dimensional (or Architectural) Asphalt ShinglesĬomparing Costs: Metal Roofs vs. The cost of upgrading to these types of shingles is still less than the price range of metal roofing. While asphalt roofing tends to come in just three categories, significant variety is available in each category -especially dimensional and luxury shingles. From steel and slate to aluminum and corrugated metal, the different materials are conducive to variety. With more types of materials to choose from than asphalt roofing, metal roofing offers a great deal of variety. Like metal roofing, the more expensive options offer more design choices at a lower price than their metal counterparts. Asphalt roofing does come in a variety of colors and styles. An asphalt roof will blend in, not calling attention to itself as much as other materials-but that can be viewed as bland to those seeking to stand out. The appearance of asphalt roofing is very familiar to people in suburban environments. One issue regarding the appearance of metal roofing is that prices tend to go up significantly to access more stylish and versatile materials.
Depending on your preferences, this can be seen as both an advantage and a disadvantage. Here is a quick breakdown: Metal RoofingĪs mentioned above, metal roofing can look rural and out of place in suburban settings. shingle roofing offers different advantages in terms of appearance.
DIY installation could void manufacturer warrantiesĪppearance of Metal Roofs vs. Many builders use similar styles and colors, resulting in a generic look. Quietly absorbs the sound of rain and hail. Can stand up well to impact from hail and debris, especially when new. Available in a wide variety of designs and colors. Can look out of place in suburban settings. Can be vulnerable to impact from hail and debris. Many are made from recyclable materials. Available in a wide range of metal types across several price ranges. Aesthetically pleasing with many design options. These tables help you compare the pros and cons of metal roofs vs. What if you’re not ready to choose between specific types of asphalt or metal roofs yet? Then simply decide between asphalt or metal.
More expensive than other types of shingles. These options include: Three-Tab Asphalt Shinglesĭimensional (or Architectural) Asphalt Shingles Differences among asphalt shingles impact the durability and cost of the shingles. There are also different types of asphalt shingles.
It might come as a surprise, but variety among asphalt shingles doesn’t just have to do with their color and appearance.
Often used as a generic term for aluminum roofing. Can be soft and relatively vulnerable to harsh conditions. More expensive than other types of metal roofing. Standing Seam / Copper Zinc Metal Roofing Here are some variations of metal roofing you will find: These vary in terms of durability, appearance, and cost. The primary difference is the type of metal used. The term “ metal roofing" describes a fairly wide variety of options. We created this ultimate guide to help you decide between metal vs. Both are popular, and each has its own set of pros and cons. The key decision is choosing between a metal roof and an asphalt shingle roof. There are two major categories of roofing available, with several options for each. Of course, the cost of a new roof is significant, and there is a large range of pricing depending on the type of roofing you choose. asphalt shingles, the aesthetic appearance of your roof is one thing, but the performance of your roof is another matter. If your roofing needs to be replaced, there are several options available to you.